A guide to making better cookies
Cookies. I love cookies. Part of the reason I was a little chunky as a kid was cookies! Who doesn’t love them? There are literally hundreds (if not thousands) of different types of cookie in existence, from countries all around the world and one of the most popular types has to be chocolate chip cookie. And that’s what this post is about!
Leave a comment with any questions/issues you have making cookies and i’ll do my best to help.
A Brief History
The humble chocolate chip cookie originates from the USA. Created “accidentally” by Ruth Wakefield during the 1930s near Whitman, Massachusetts. Apparently Wakefield was trying to make Chocolate Drop cookies to an old colonial recipe, but was out of cocoa powder so she chopped up some semi sweet Nestle chocolate hoping it would spread evenly through the cookies during baking. This, of course doesn’t happen. The chocolate kind of holds its shape a bit as it melts, but the sugars in the chocolate change as they caramelize from the heat in the oven and then set as the cookies cool. This results in crispy edges and a soft gooey middle, which we all love!
My recipe for chocolate chip cookies is very similar to the kind of recipe Ruth Wakefield would have used- like a chocolate drop cookie, using brown sugar as well as white to give a softer texture, and a bit of bicarb to make them lighter. The main difference is I’ve added some eggs to make these cookies richer, and I’ve adjusted the amount of flour, butter and sugar to compensate.
Chips vs chunks vs flakes
What we all know about cookies from our childhoods is probably that we should use chocolate chips. After all, they’re called Chocolate Chip Cookies right? Well for a long time now i’ve been using chocolate chunks or flakes instead. That is, taking a big block or bar of chocolate and chopping it up myself. It’s one of those things I have been doing for ages but never consciously thought about why. So for the purpose of this blog post I asked myself that exact question and I came up with this reasoning (bare with me!):
Complexity + Variety = Interest
This is something I think applies to nature and the world in general. It’s the lack of uniformity which makes it better.
So in the context of chocolate in cookies, it means that we are going to have lots of different size bits of chocolate in our mixture. Some of these bigger pieces might have long sharp edges, and will give us a real chewy chocolate hit during a bite, whilst the smaller flakes will be better dispersed in the cookie and will melt into the mix much better.
I also had a quick look online and saw that other people were saying pretty much exactly what i’ve just told you. So maybe i’m on to something!
The right chocolate for you
The other advantage to using “real” chocolate pieces instead of buying chips from the supermarket is QUALITY.
So here i’m using my own chocolate, as I really do believe chocolate chip cookies are only as good as the chocolate you use.
Since the cookie mix is generally quite sweet, I think a higher percentage chocolate is a good choice, but this recipe will work for any chocolate so I’ll leave that choice to you!
I’m using our Tresuro Oscuro. This 85% Colombian Dark Chocolate is by far one of our best sellers and one of my favourites.
With these cookies, I’m taking 2 and putting our classic caramel between them and then dipping them in our Ben Tre (45% Vietnam Milk Chocolate) to create the ultimate snack. If you want me to do a top up post giving you the full recipe leave a comment and i’ll do one as soon as I can.
Let me know how you get on with this recipe. I love seeing what you have made so share and tag on Facebook and Instagram. Give us a follow and say hi!
- 345 g Plain flour
- 1 tsp bicarbonate of soda
- 1 tsp salt
- 230 g Unsalted butter, softened to room temperature
- 200 g Brown sugar
- 100 g Granulated sugar
- 2 large Eggs room temperature
- 2 tsp pure Vanilla extract (or 1 tsp vanilla paste)
- 450g Chocolate Flakes
- Put all ingredients apart from the chocolate into a food processor.
- Blitz until combined.
- Go to step 5.
- Combine dry ingredients (Flour, Bicarb, Salt)
- In a mixer with the paddle attachment, mix the Brown & White sugar and Butter until light & fluffy.
- Gradually mix in the eggs and vanilla.
- Add the dry ingredients. Mix until combined.
- Stir in the chocolate flakes so they are just mixed in.
- Cover with cling film and rest in the fridge for at least 1 hour.
- Preheat your oven to 180°c (160°c Fan) Gas mark 4.
- Using your hands, shape the dough into balls a little bigger than a £2 coin and place on a baking tray lined with parchment. Make sure to leave some space between cookies as they will spread during cooking.
- Press each ball down slightly to flatten the top.
- Bake for 10-12 minutes until the edges are light brown and the tops are still soft.
- Leave to cool on the try and then transfer to a wire rack until cold.
- Store in an airtight tub for up to 1 week.
Large Single Origin Easter Egg£60.00 Select options
Mixed chocolate “Duck” Easter Eggs£15.00 Add to cart
Chocolate Flakes£4.95 Select options
“Staying In” Care Pack£20.00 Add to cart
White Chocolate Single Origin Easter Egg£20.00 Add to cart
Milk Chocolate Single Origin Easter Egg£20.00 Select options
Dark Chocolate Single Origin Easter Egg£20.00 Select options
Single Origin Chocolate Bar 12 Pack£55.00 Add to cart
Dark Bar 6 Pack£30.00 Add to cart
Dairy Bar 6 Pack£30.00 Add to cart
38% Colombia Blonde£5.50 Add to cart
62% Madagascar Milk£5.50 Add to cart
50% Ghana Milk£5.50 Add to cart
45% Ben Tre£5.50 Add to cart
Family Easter Course£60.00 Select options
Taste Tuesday£10.00 – £100.00 Select options